The Passing of the Man within the Grey Flannel Swimsuit

In an period of quickly altering cultural, sexual, and social mores, one shocking growth got here and went with out a lot remark. In 2019, Goldman Sachs introduced that it was stress-free its famously strict costume code. Excessive finance, lengthy a bastion of suit-and-tie traditionalism, had lastly surrendered to the encroaching forces of “enterprise informal.”

Goldman’s white flag was a lagging, not a number one, indicator of developments inside American workforces. Ailing-matched khaki and costume shirt pairings have been de rigueur in lots of workplaces for the reason that mid-’90s. The tech trade, which has supplanted finance because the profession of selection for bold strivers, overtly disdains office formality. Disgraced crypto mogul Sam Bankman-Fried famously used his informal wardrobe to woo potential marks. Credulous buyers thought that they had discovered the subsequent Mark Zuckerberg. What they acquired was Bernie Madoff in sweatpants.


What occurred to American menswear? It’s not shocking that the nation that invented blue denims and informal Fridays more and more eschews tailor-made clothes. As costume codes calm down and jackets and ties turn into a rarity, nonetheless, males are caught between the few events that also require formality and a wider society that has opted for consolation over presentation.

The relentless advance of enterprise informal is each a trigger and an impact of the decline of the home garment trade. Brooks Brothers, arguably the exemplar of tailor-made American clothes, declared chapter in 2020. The post-bankruptcy restoration plan for the corporate that when made a customized frock coat for Abraham Lincoln entails a shift to informal put on and a brand new mascot, Henry the Sheep. Ralph Lauren and J. Crew, mass market inheritors to the fashion popularized by Brooks, make most of their garments abroad. Even informal clothiers and suppliers aren’t proof against fickle client developments and worldwide competitors. Cone Mills, the final selvedge denim mill in america, produced its ultimate yard of cloth in 2018.

The unfold of informal costume codes and the autumn of Brooks Brothers sign the decline of a distinctively American fashion of clothes. Though much less formal than Europeans, Individuals are inheritors to a practice of tailor-made menswear that displays our historical past and habits. This custom is in peril of disappearing, or no less than turning into the unique province of well-heeled hobbyists.

If Britain is the daddy of contemporary menswear, america is its extra relaxed youthful brother. Typically referred to as “Ivy” or “East Coast” fashion by aficionados, American suiting has a number of delicate distinguishing options. Because the title “Ivy” implies, this custom was formed by our most privileged establishments, however it additionally has some strikingly egalitarian options. “I feel we’re a bit extra informal and fewer keen on issues equivalent to strict social hierarchy and inherited titles,” says fashion critic Derek Man. “So whenever you take a look at [American tailoring], it displays this common liberal, democratic angle.”

G. Bruce Boyer, a veteran menswear observer and former editor at GQ, Esquire, and City & Nation, says that the construction of the American swimsuit displays our extra relaxed social conventions. “Stylistically, Ivy tailoring has a softer look and feel than the British clothes: the Brits assemble a extra architecturally constructed swimsuit which has a tougher, extra particular, and built-up cleaner form with the next shoulder and nipped waist and flared skirt.”


The nation that pioneered mass manufacturing introduced the same sensibility to its tailor-made clothes. “The Brooks Brother swimsuit, which they named their No. 1 Sack Swimsuit when it debuted on the flip of the century, grew to become one of many cornerstones of the Ivy look,” explains Man. “It featured a barely softer, pure shoulder, and machine stitched lapels.”

“The final half is essential as a result of American tailoring has all the time been somewhat extra about mass manufacturing than its European counterparts,” he continues. “Brooks Brothers invented ready-made tailoring within the mid-nineteenth century, and their lapels on the flip of the 20 th century featured a machine completed edge.”

(Photograph by Max Mumby/Indigo/Getty Pictures)

Past the swimsuit and tie, twentieth century American tailoring was characterised by different informal options. Man cites “the unlined oxford material button-down, which has a pleasant rumpled character, the two-piece swimsuit as daywear (differing from our European counterparts, who wore the three-piece), [and] slip-on footwear with enterprise fits. Suppose Cary Grant in fits and tassel loafers—extraordinary on the flip of the 20 th century, particularly in London.”

In the present day, the concept that sporting a swimsuit with tassel loafers is informal appears charmingly anachronistic. However in years previous, thumbing your nostril at formality was a solution to sign your populist bona fides. Within the 1890 congressional elections, “Sockless” Jerry Simpson received notoriety for mocking the silk hosiery of the railroad magnate he was operating in opposition to. His opponent replied thatsilk stockings had been higher than no stockings in any respect, however Simpson received the vote. Two years later, firebrand socialist Member of Parliament Keir Hardie shocked his colleagues by sporting tweed and a material cap within the Home of Commons. “It was as if a purple flag had been raised in Westminster,” wrote historian Barbara Tuchman. Within the twentieth century, beatniks, hippies, antiwar protesters, and varied different countercultural teams would undertake informal or distinctive garments as social or political signifiers.

Dressing informally was as soon as a subversive gesture, however in an period of sweatpants and Crocs, foregoing a swimsuit and tie has misplaced its edge. Furthermore, the buttoned-up guidelines of yesteryear had a lot to suggest. Modern vogue is overwhelmingly drawn from youth subcultures and sports activities, which suggests the garments are designed to be worn by the younger and match. The center-aged, the portly, and the couch-bound are unlikely to look good in “athleisure” or a t-shirt and denims. A well-cut swimsuit, with its broad shoulders and trim waist, is designed to artfully conceal (or no less than de-emphasize) age and infirmity.

Formal enterprise apparel is usually derided as stuffy and elitist, however the outdated workplace costume codes had been a lot simpler to comply with than the ambiguous directives of “enterprise informal.” The Goldman Sachs announcement notably omitted any info on what constitutes applicable workplace apparel. Staff had been left to make use of their very own greatest judgment.

The category implications of enterprise casual-ification are apparent. Over the previous decade, a baroque canon of social justice-inflected language and conduct has overtaken academia, media, massive enterprise, and authorities. Universities now impart guidelines of conduct which are no less than as opaque as any bygone code of aristocratic etiquette. Like most codes, these guidelines are supposed to distinguish outsiders from these within the know. Navigating the unusual new world of enterprise informal requires simply as a lot savoir faire.

“All of us know what’s and isn’t applicable for the office,” the Goldman Sachs costume code memo ominously intoned. If you happen to’ve gone to the suitable colleges and gotten the suitable internships, maybe you perceive the delicate gradations of enterprise informal. For outsiders, tailor-made clothes has been changed by one thing altogether extra complicated.

(Photograph by Thomas Lohnes/Getty Pictures)

In distinction, “the suit-and-tie uniform was a simple, democratic answer in an age of a rising city center class,” says Boyer. “It made identification simple, and any delicate manifestations of particular person fashion might be left to the whims of persona.”

Then there may be the matter of aesthetics. As a substitute of liberating us to pursue our most outrageous or inventive fancies, informal costume codes have resulted in an undifferentiated mass of sneakers, t-shirts, and joggers. Within the company world, fits and ties have been supplanted by schlubby fleece vests. As soon as derided as an emblem of staid conformity, the person within the grey flannel swimsuit appears a relic from a halcyon age, a Roman statue pulled down by a horde of marauding barbarians in sweatpants.

It’s not that males are out of the blue tired of dressing properly. Devotees of tailor-made clothes nonetheless argue over materials, shirt collar proportions, and the delicate variations between American, British, and Italian tailoring. Related subcultures exist for sneakers, streetwear, navy surplus, workwear, and a bunch of different kinds. As with so many hobbies, the Web has been a boon to the true fanatic.

What was as soon as a part of the broader tradition, nonetheless, is more and more restricted to aficionados with the money and time to immerse themselves in tailor-made clothes. Those that don’t care about decide stitching or the intricacies of a sevenfold tie have fewer alternatives to soak up the fundamental guidelines of formal costume and fewer alternatives to place these guidelines into apply. Enterprise casual-ification has left males confused and adrift, uncertain of easy methods to costume for events that also demand formality.

Is there a cheerful medium between tracksuits and a slavish devotion to the costumes of yesteryear? In some ways, the challenges dealing with the home clothes trade mirror broader modifications inside American society. “[In the] mid-twentieth century, most American males would have had a couple of respectable ready-made tailor-made clothes,” says Boyer. “However over the a long time since then the center has hollowed out. Most males have drifted towards the informal finish, whereas a couple of have moved in the direction of the bespoke (increased tailoring) finish. The result’s that there is not any center any extra.”

A few of these challenges are related to structural financial components. Brooks Brothers’ latest struggles prompted it to shut factories in New York, Massachusetts, and North Carolina, citing slim margins and competitors with low-cost international labor. But altering client tastes and unhealthy enterprise choices additionally performed a job within the decline of an iconic American model. Elsewhere, Man has famous that Brooks was hamstrung by company over-expansion and a sequence of pricy retail leases.

For the home garment trade to outlive, Individuals could must recuperate a shared understanding of how and why to decorate up. Internet hosting a cocktail party or planning a marriage with a relaxed costume code is not novel or thrilling, and a simple swimsuit and tie requirement is simpler to decipher than “inventive cocktail apparel” (no matter meaning) and yields higher images, anyway. It’s additionally good to carry an elevated sensibility to sure occasions. “One of many social developments that I am notably frightened about is that we’re shedding our sense of event,” says Boyer. “I see folks at weddings, funerals, graduations and commencements sporting the identical garments they’d to rake leaves.”

(Getty Pictures)

Males nonetheless wish to costume properly. The romantic aura that adheres to figures like Cary Grant and John F. Kennedy is proof sufficient that tailor-made clothes retains its attraction. In some ways, the problem of reviving formal put on displays a broader stress inside conservatism. Particularly, how can we maintain or recuperate traditions which have already been eroded by diffuse cultural, financial, and social components?

There aren’t any apparent solutions, however within the meantime, I’ve a couple of modest strategies for males who wish to enhance their wardrobes. Begin with a navy or charcoal grey swimsuit and darkish costume footwear. In relation to tailoring, the hoary cliche “purchase much less, purchase higher” continues to be a helpful information: swimsuit and pair of footwear will last more and look higher than a closet filled with low-cost knock-offs. Discover a respectable tailor who may also help you get fitted to your physique kind. And for God’s sake, don’t put on “enjoyable socks.”